
Disappointed, I tossed it in the fridge and went to bed. This morning I discovered that it had firmed up! It tasted pretty good despite the appearance. So maaaayyybbbee it wasn't a complete disaster. I did some research online and read about baking with water baths and that's what I did with my second attempt (also lowering the temp a bit).

Look at how different it looks! It's chillin in the fridge right now. Hope it's good.
Update:

Smallest slice ever! Topped with blueberry sauce. Not bad at all!